The VA bilateral factor is intended to account for qualifying disabilities involving both sides of certain paired body structures. In some combinations, however, its calculation can produce a less favorable result. Current 38 CFR § 4.26(d) requires VA to exclude one or more bilateral disabilities from that calculation and combine them separately when doing so produces the more favorable combined evaluation (38 C.F.R. § 4.26, 2026).
The practical answer is therefore two-part: the calculation can produce the lower number, but the current exception addresses that result. It is not a general instruction to turn the bilateral factor off. VA’s own published example shows why comparing the permitted calculations matters.
This is general education, not individualized claims advice. Meritwright LLC and Norivault are independent of VA. They do not decide official ratings, represent claimants, or guarantee a benefit increase.
What the bilateral factor actually adds
Under § 4.26, qualifying ratings are first combined. Ten percent of that combined value is then added to it before further combinations. That is not a flat 10-percentage-point addition to a Veteran’s final rating. For two qualifying 10% evaluations, the combined value is 19; its bilateral addition is 1.9, producing 20.9 before the rounding shown in VA’s example (38 C.F.R. § 4.26, 2026).
Applicability matters before arithmetic. The regulation addresses both arms, both legs, or paired skeletal muscles, with compensable disability in each paired extremity or paired skeletal muscle. Disabilities do not have to affect identical joints on opposite sides. A left-sided and right-sided diagnosis alone does not establish that a particular calculation is appropriate; check the regulatory criteria and the evaluations actually assigned (38 C.F.R. § 4.26, 2026).
Why combining and rounding are different steps
VA’s combined ratings table does not simply add disability percentages. It combines ratings in severity order and carries intermediate table results forward. Conversion to the nearest multiple of 10 is performed at the end, with a final value ending in 5 rounded upward. Do not round every intermediate result to the nearest 10 (38 C.F.R. § 4.25, 2026).
This distinction explains the importance of 94 versus 95. The final conversion sends 94 to 90%, but 95 to 100%. Intermediate whole-number rounding in VA’s published example affects which side of that threshold the calculation reaches. A spreadsheet that retains every decimal until the end will not reproduce the example unless it follows the same intermediate steps.
VA’s 90% versus 100% example
The April 2023 rulemaking starts with other disabilities already combined to 93%, plus two qualifying 10% evaluations. The 93 is an intermediate combined value, not an individual 93% disability rating or a final rounded award. The table below follows VA’s example (Exceptions to Applying the Bilateral Factor, 2023a, p. 22915).
| Step | Bilateral group | Separate ratings |
|---|---|---|
| Starting value | 93 | 93 |
| Process the two 10% evaluations | Combine to 19; add 1.9; round 20.9 to 21 | Keep each 10 separate |
| Next combination | 93 with 21 gives 94.47, rounded to 94 | 93 with 10 gives 93.7, rounded to 94 |
| Remaining combination | None | 94 with 10 gives 94.6, rounded to 95 |
| Final conversion | 94 becomes 90% | 95 becomes 100% |
The values can be checked using the remaining-efficiency relationship: combine A and B as A + (100 − A) × B ÷ 100, following the example’s intermediate rounding. That gives 93 + 7 × 0.21 = 94.47 in the grouped path. In the separate path, the first whole-number result is 94, so the next calculation is 94 + 6 × 0.10 = 94.6. These are reconstructions of the published example, not a replacement for the combined ratings table or an assessment of an individual case.
The difference is not an extra disability or an invented percentage. It comes from grouping and intermediate rounding before the final conversion. For this example, paragraph (d) provides the more favorable path.
The exception is broader than the headline example
The interim rule took effect April 16, 2023. VA adopted it without changes in its December 27, 2023 final rule. Importantly, the final rule expressly recognized limited scenarios where an 80% combined evaluation could become 90%. The regulatory exception is not restricted to people moving from 90% to 100% (Exceptions to Applying the Bilateral Factor, 2023b).
Nor does it necessarily require removing every qualifying disability from the bilateral group. The operative text addresses one or more disabilities when separate combination produces a more favorable evaluation. A simple on/off checkbox may not fully represent that instruction (38 C.F.R. § 4.26, 2026).
In April 2023, VA described an implementation review of affected evaluations running on the rule’s effective date without requiring a new claim from those identified Veterans. That historical statement does not establish that a particular person’s current evaluation has been checked or changed (Exceptions to Applying the Bilateral Factor, 2023a).
A practical verification checklist
Before relying on an estimate, keep a short calculation record:
- Record the source of each individual evaluation, the affected side or extremity where relevant, and the effective date. Do not replace an assigned percentage with a percentage you hope to receive.
- Separate source information from assumptions. If bilateral applicability is uncertain, write down the question instead of silently selecting a setting.
- Identify what the calculator actually does. Does it show only a grouped calculation, allow a manual alternative, or document comparison under paragraph (d)? Do not infer this from the phrase bilateral-factor support.
- Preserve intermediate whole-number results and the final conversion separately. A screenshot showing only a final percentage is not a complete calculation trail.
- Keep the rule link and the calculation date alongside your notes. If results disagree, compare the inputs and steps before drawing conclusions about the award.
- Bring unresolved questions to VA or a verified VA-accredited representative. An online estimate is a starting point for a question, not proof that a decision is incorrect.
You can keep this record on paper or in a protected local workspace. If your notes contain medical, service, or identity information, avoid posting unredacted screenshots in public forums. Our private evidence-organization guide offers a related method for keeping sources and working notes distinct.
Getting help and using planning software responsibly
An accredited VSO representative, claims agent, or attorney can help with an individual claim or decision review. VA provides a tool for finding accredited help; it does not automatically assign a representative to everyone (U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, 2026). Do not treat this example as a reason to assume a specific review path, effective date, or retroactive payment applies to you.
Norivault Desktop, available for Windows and macOS, offers a local-first workspace with a 38 CFR Part 4 reference library and unofficial rating-planning tools, including bilateral-factor support where applicable. Those features can support research and organization, but bilateral-factor support alone should not be interpreted as a promise that a particular version automatically evaluates every paragraph (d) alternative. Check the installed version’s documented behavior and compare its steps with current official sources. VA alone makes official benefit and disability-rating determinations.
References
- Bilateral factor, 38 C.F.R. § 4.26 (2026). https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-38/chapter-I/part-4/subpart-A/section-4.26 (opens in a new tab)
- Combined ratings table, 38 C.F.R. § 4.25 (2026). https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-38/chapter-I/part-4/subpart-A/section-4.25 (opens in a new tab)
- Exceptions to applying the bilateral factor in VA disability calculations, 88 Fed. Reg. 22914 (April 14, 2023) (interim final rule). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/04/14/2023-07426/exceptions-to-applying-the-bilateral-factor-in-va-disability-calculations (opens in a new tab)
- Exceptions to applying the bilateral factor in VA disability calculations, 88 Fed. Reg. 89307 (December 27, 2023) (final rule). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/12/27/2023-28241/exceptions-to-applying-the-bilateral-factor-in-va-disability-calculations (opens in a new tab)
- U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. (2026, September 23). Get help from a VA accredited representative or VSO. https://www.va.gov/get-help-from-accredited-representative/ (opens in a new tab)